2020
|
Booklist Starred Review
|
The Stone Wall
|
2017
|
Christian Retailing's BEST Award (Amish Fiction)
|
The Atonement
|
2015
|
Christian Retailing's BEST Award (Amish Fiction)
|
The River
|
2013
|
Christian Retailing's BEST Award (Amish Fiction)
|
The Bridesmaid
Home to Hickory Hollow |
2011
|
| Christy Award Nomination (Contemporary Series) |
The Thorn
The Rose Trilogy #1 |
| 2010 |
| Retailer's Choice Award |
The Missing
Seasons of Grace #2 |
| Career Achievement Award for Inspirational Fiction (Romantic Times Book Reviews) |
| 2009 |
| Library Journal (Best Books of 2009) |
The Missing
Seasons of Grace #2 |
| Outstanding Achievement in "Letters" by The National League of American Pen Women |
| 2008 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Redemption of Sarah Cain |
| ECPA Platinum Book Award (1,000,000 sold) |
The Shunning
The Heritage Of Lancaster County #1 |
| Retailer's Choice Award |
The Parting
The Courtship of Nellie Fisher #1 |
| 2007 |
| Christy Award (Contemporary Series) |
The Brethren
Annie's People #3 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Crossroad
The Postcard / The Crossroad series |
| 2006 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Postcard
The Postcard / The Crossroad series |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Covenant
Abram's Daughters #1 |
| 2005 |
| Library Journal (Best Genre Fiction 2005) |
The Preacher's Daughter
Annie's People #1 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Confession
The Heritage Of Lancaster County #2 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Reckoning
The Heritage Of Lancaster County #3 |
| 2004 |
| Crossings Book of the Year |
The Prodigal
Abram's Daughters #4 |
| Inspirational Readers Choice First Place Award (Long Historical) |
The Betrayal
Abram's Daughters #2 |
| 2003 |
| Distinguished Alumnus Award (Evangel University) |
| 2002 |
| ECPA Gold Book Award (500,000 sold) |
The Shunning
The Heritage Of Lancaster County #1 |
| Benjamin Franklin Award (Silver Seal) |
October Song |
| Silver Angel Award |
Sanctuary (with David Lewis) |
| 2001 |
| Silver Angel Award |
Annika's Secret Wish (picture book) |
| 2000 |
| Silver Angel Award |
The Postcard
The Postcard / The Crossroad series |
| 1997 |
| C. S. Lewis Noteworthy List |
A Cry in the Dark
Summerhill Secrets #5 |
| C. S. Lewis Noteworthy List |
The Mystery of Case D. Luc
Cul-de-Sac Kids #6 |
| 1995 |
| C. S. Lewis Noteworthy List |
Whispers Down the LaneSummerhill Secrets #1 |
